Order now to get your books by Christmas.

#ThrowbackThursday

John Tanner

1778–1850 · born in Hopkinton, Rhode Island

He lent $2,000 to save the land the Kirtland Temple stood on. Nine years later, he handed back the note.

The Kirtland Temple in Kirtland, Ohio
The Kirtland Temple in Kirtland, Ohio. Jack E. Boucher, Historic American Buildings Survey, Library of Congress (public domain)

Part 1

Leaving on Christmas Day

In the fall of 1834, John Tanner sold “two large farms and two thousand and two hundred acres of timber land” around Bolton, his home on Lake George in northern New York. He was fifty-six. Two years earlier, he had been baptized in that lake, and now he meant to take his household west to gather with the Saints. He planned to start in the spring.

It was a great deal to leave. John had, as his son Nathan remembered, “a delightful home on the west side of Lake George, one of the finest sheets of water in the world.” Besides the farms, there were sawmills, orchards, and a hotel at Bolton Landing. “None of our means was willed to us,” Nathan said, “but earned by hard work and economy.”

About the middle of December, John “received an impression by dream or vision of the night, that he was needed and must go immediately to the Church in the West.” He told his family, and they began getting ready at once.

His neighbors, “with deep regret at what they considered an insane purpose,” tried their utmost to talk him out of going in the winter. But “he knew the will of God in the present crisis and nothing could deter him from doing it.”

On Christmas Day 1834, they started for Kirtland, in northeastern Ohio, where the Church had its headquarters and the Saints were building their first temple. John’s wife, Elizabeth, who made the trip with him, wrote that he “started with his family bringing his sons and their wives also four neighbors families numbering in all about forty five souls.” They took with them “several good teams a stock of merchandise and considerable money.”

One of those married sons was Sidney, twenty-five, who came with his wife, Louisa. John’s youngest child, Joseph Smith Tanner, was eighteen months old, the first child born after his father joined the Church. Elizabeth, thirty-one, was expecting another baby.

The Tanner wagons rolled out in the dead of winter. The Erie Canal, the usual way west across New York, was frozen and closed until spring, and they had five hundred miles to cover by road. They were nearly four weeks on the way. They reached Kirtland in January 1835, on a Sunday.

They found the Church “in great difficulty for want of money to pay for the farm which the temple was being built on,” Elizabeth wrote. The farm was mortgaged, and the mortgage had come due. Notice had been given that the money must be paid the day after the Tanners arrived.

John learned something else in Kirtland, and his family has told it ever since. At the time his dream came, Joseph Smith and some of the brethren had met in a prayer meeting. They had asked the Lord “to send them a brother or some brethren with means to assist them to lift the mortgage on the farm upon which the temple was being built.”

The day after the Tanners arrived, the very day the money was due, John and Sidney met with the high council at the Prophet’s invitation. There they were told the temple farm was about to be foreclosed. “He immediately loaned two thousand dollars for that purpose,” Elizabeth wrote. John took Joseph Smith’s note for it, and the family remembered that the farm was redeemed with that money.

He did not stop there. One of the three men on the committee overseeing the temple’s building was Jared Carter, the missionary at whose word John had walked again two years before. To that committee, John lent thirteen thousand dollars in goods, priced at what they had cost in New York, “besides donating liberally for the building of the house,” as Elizabeth put it.

Sixty years later, his son Nathan, speaking to the gathered family, put it in his father’s own terms: “My father used to say he enjoyed accumulating property around him, and if it could be spent wisely, it would prove a blessing. If spent otherwise, it would prove a curse.”

Elizabeth Tanner, who made the winter trip with John, wrote down her memories late in life. The dream, the neighbors’ objections, and the prayer meeting in Kirtland come from a sketch of John’s life by his grandson, printed in 1883. The sums are what the family remembered; no account book from that time has been found to confirm them.

Part 2

Brother Joseph, You Are Welcome to It

At the April 1844 conference in Nauvoo, Illinois, John Tanner was called on a mission to the Eastern States. He was sixty-five, and among the Saints he was known as Father Tanner. Joseph Smith was running for president of the United States that year, and John was one of the elders sent east to preach and to gather support for him. John farmed across the Mississippi in Iowa, about four miles from Montrose. Before he set out, he went over to Nauvoo with a piece of paper he had kept for more than nine years.

It was Joseph Smith’s note for $2,000, his signed promise to pay the money back. John had taken it in Kirtland, Ohio, in January 1835, when he lent the money to save the land the temple was being built on.

Since then, nearly everything he owned had gone. The bank Church leaders had started in Kirtland failed in 1837, and in the words of his son Nathan, “This left Father without anything.” The family set out for Missouri with twenty dollars, a hundredth of what Joseph’s note was worth.

The Tanners came to Iowa in 1840 and started over. At first, John’s son Myron remembered, “our diet consisted almost exclusively of corn bread and milk”, and sometimes they ran out of corn. In time, they fenced hundreds of acres, and the farm prospered.

John held a second note as well. In Kirtland, he had supplied goods to the committee building the temple, and the committee had given him a note of its own. In 1842, after holding it for seven years, John went to Joseph’s brother Hyrum Smith and asked whether it would be all right to sell it. Hyrum said it would be all right. John sold it for about $300.

Joseph’s own note for $2,000 he still had.

John met Joseph on a street in Nauvoo and handed it to him. Joseph did not understand what he meant by it, and he asked what John wanted done with it.

John answered, “Brother Joseph, you are welcome to it.”

Joseph laid his right hand heavily on John’s shoulder. “God bless you, Father Tanner; you and your children shall never beg for bread.”

It was the last time John saw Joseph; before he came home from the East, Joseph had been killed at Carthage.

His family never let go of the promise. His descendants came to believe it reached all of them, through the lean years of settling Utah and through hard times long after. Tanner descendants tell how, during the Great Depression, John’s grandchildren and great-grandchildren joked that they wished Joseph had included jam and butter in the blessing.

The family has told this story since John’s own children’s day, and it was first printed in 1883 in a sketch of his life by his grandson Nathan Tanner Jr. Later family histories repeat it nearly word for word. The $2,000 is the sum the family remembered; no record from the time confirms the amount. Some copies give Joseph’s words as “your children shall never beg bread.”

His children, and their children

FamilySearch's public tree shows 3,089 of John Tanner's descendants in the first four generations, counting only those who have passed away. Everyone living comes after them.

Children
20
Grandchildren
164
Great-grandchildren
818
Great-great-grandchildren
2,087

Is John Tanner your ancestor?

Sign in with FamilySearch and our free Famous Ancestors search checks your tree for John and thousands of other people from history.

Find out free

Every family has stories like this one. We turn your family's FamilySearch memories into a printed Ancestor Stories book.